|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Ice
vs. Heat
|
|
By: Dr. James Thor
National Director of Extreme Sports Medicine
|
|
|
|
Some of us can probably remember when
our parents or grandparents would put heat on aches and pains to relieve
the discomfort. Back then,
that was the prescribed method of treatment.
With today’s technology, we know better.
There is a time for ice and a time for heat.
Which one is the question? 99%
of the time, you won’t go wrong by applying ice to something that hurts.
|
|
|
To understand
why ice works, we need to understand how an injury works.
Let’s say we sustain a fall and twist a wrist.
What actually happens when we twist a wrist?
We stretch things far out of proportion from where nature intended
them to be. Muscles tear, as can ligaments.
Skin can be stretched. Joints
are moved beyond what would be considered a normal range of motion.
Most importantly, the very small arteries and veins tear.
That leads to bleeding. Then
the blood and the fluid that accompanies the blood starts to occupy places
where fluid is not meant to be. Nerves
are compressed, damaged, possibly even torn.
The area becomes stiff and painful.
The pain is the alarm that limits you in your actions so that
further damage is prevented. When
ice is applied to a sprain/strain like the one described, what takes place
is the contraction of the small arteries and veins under the cold.
This is a natural reaction to conserve body heat.
In a situation involving injury, the contraction of the arteries
results in less bleeding, less pooling of fluid, and the lessening of
overall swelling. This damage
usually takes between 48 and 72 hours to slow down and stop. |
|
|
The repair
process involves the body causing the bleeding to stop on its own, if it
has the time to rest. That is
why immobilization of a strain or sprain is necessary. The ice stops the bleeding.
Immobilization stops further tearing and further injury. |
|
|
Once the
condition is under control and 48 hours have passed, heat can be applied.
Heat is used at this time to promote some circulation, returning
blood flow to the damaged area. Returning
blood flow to the affected area at the proper time also results in the
return of fresh food, fresh oxygen, and an increase in the body’s
ability to remove some of the waste products of the old blood and damaged
tissue. |
|
|
Ice and heat are
applied for approximately the same length of time.
When applying ice, try not to exceed 20 minutes.
Application for a longer period of time may increase the risk of
frostbite, which can kill and ulcerate the skin and leave the patient
prone to infection. Remember, if there is an open wound along with the injury, or
if the skin has been torn open, seek the advice of professional medical
personnel. The easiest way to
recognize frostbite is its similarity to a burn.
The skin will be swollen and raised.
If ice is left on too long and this condition appears, seek medical
help. |
|
| The main problem
encountered by patients applying heat is leaving the heat on too long.
20 to 30 minutes is plenty for a comfortable application of heat.
Excessive heat can burn the skin, possibly leaving ulcerations and
an increased susceptibility to infection.
If this occurs, seek medical attention.
Heat can be applied in different ways for different injuries.
For example, for a strained wrist or ankle, a hot bath would be the
best option after 72 hours, soaking well for 20 to 30 minutes in water
that is quite warm but not scalding. If there is some discomfort to a back after an initial injury
and following the use of ice, a heating pad would be the method of choice.
Do not lie on a heating pad, however, because the electric fibers
that are present in a heating pad can cause burns.
The patient can sit against a heating pad or have the heating pad
lying on the affected area, but should not lie on the heating pad.
The heating pad should have a timer, or the patient may have
someone else present to make sure the patient does not fall asleep with
the heating pad on. This can
lead to serious burns and is probably the biggest mistake made when
applying heat. |
|
|
Some basic tips
to remember: With an acute
strain/sprain, ice the affected area and elevate it.
Elevation is always best if it is above heart level.
The reason is gravity. It
is more difficult for blood to run uphill than downhill.
This also prevents the bleeding from becoming excessive in an acute
injury.
|
|
|
Many athletes
ask when compression bandages should be used during a sprain/strain
injury. Please seek medical
advice regarding the use of compression bandages in each case, as
different conditions and complications dictate different methods of
treatment. If only ice,
followed by heat, is used, the patient will be well on the road to healing
and recovery. |
|
|
Remember, if the
condition persists or continues to get worse, seek medical advice at
around the 72 hour mark. If
there is a suspicion of a serious injury, such as a bone fracture, always
have it checked by a medical professional.
Injuries that are not properly cared for can keep us all from
becoming champions.
|
|
|
|
|
|